英语辩论：愚公应不应该移山?求反方陈词

英语辩论：愚公应不应该移山?求反方陈词
最好是初二能懂的……

今天,我方观点是愚公应该搬家.
众所周知,《愚公移山》出于《列子*汤问》,它的前篇是“淮南的橘到了淮北就变成了枳”,它的后篇是“夸父追日”,很显然,原著是要通过这三篇寓言告诉我们,做事不能违背自然规律,不能一味蛮干.愚公的精神可嘉,但做法不可取,我方认为,愚公不应该移山,而应该搬家.
第一,移山破坏自然.愚公移山所带来的哪怕是一两次泥石流,也足够让愚公走向我方观点----搬家了!
第二,移山会对生态造成不良影响.还记得那句经典台词吗：悟空你可真调皮呀,叫你不要乱扔东西呀!砸到小朋友那可怎么办呀,就算砸不到小朋友,砸到花花草草也不好呀!愚公移山,可就不只是砸到花花草草这么简单了!千千万万的动植物将失去自己的家园.而搬家起码可以免去唐僧的唠叨.
第三,给他人造成损失.愚公移山,成日叮叮当当的不说,还有一些没多少文化的人“跳往助之”,须知“京城氏之孀妻,有遗男,始龀”,同学们,这可是吸取知识的年龄呀!唉!难怪连神都看不下去.
第四,愚公的子孙真的能“无穷匮”吗?愚公全家去移山了,谁种地?我就不明白了,愚公会有能养活全家的退休工资?另外,这样不可理喻的家庭,对方辩友口口声声称赞,难道对方四位女辩友愿意到这样的家庭去移山?就算他后代找到了媳妇,哪里有时间生孩子?就算生下了孩子,哪里有时间去照顾?就算孩子长大了,难道也会像父辈、祖辈一样不可理喻?与其把无尽的负担压给后人,倒不如搬到一番新天地,可以代代欢乐.
第五,客观上愚公移山也不可能成功.须知“太行、王屋二山,方七百里,高万仞”,那是一个什么概念?粗略计算一下,两座山约合土石234万亿吨.愚公把土运到“渤海之尾,隐土之北”,就算每年往返一次,每次5吨,也要五千个100亿年.而科学家告诉我们,地球的寿命总共是100亿年左右,也就是说当人类都把家搬到了太空,并且对地球无限缅怀的时候,愚公还在不曾毁山之一角啊!
综上所述,移山费时费力、害人害己、而且违背自然规律；而搬家经济实惠,效率高,前景好,而且环保.
山不转,水要转,水不转了,人要转,面临如此两座大山,毫无疑问,愚公应该搬家.
谢谢!
翻译：Today, our view is that the old man should move.
As everyone knows,
"great determination and courage" for "Liezi * Tang asked", its predecessor is
"Huainan orange to Huaibei became Zhi", it is "in pursuit of the sun after",
obviously, the original is to tell us through the three fable, do not violate
the laws of nature, not a foolhardy. The foolish old man's spirit is
commendable, but the practice is not desirable, I think, the foolish old man
should not remove mountains, but should move.
First, remove the
destruction of natural. Even the great determination and courage which is
brought by the one or two debris flow, is enough for the old man to our view,
move!
Second, the mountains have adverse effects on the ecological.
Remember the classic lines like: when you can really naughty, ask you not to
throw things! It hit the children that may be how do ah, even if not to drop it
on the children, down to the flowers is not okay! Great determination and
courage, can not just down to the flowers so simple! Thousands on thousands of
plants and animals will lose their homes. Move at least can be removed from the
Tang's monk's nagging.
Third, and causes losses to others. Great
determination and courage, always a tinkling did not say, there are not many
cultural people "jump to help," notes "the capital's widow, has left male, was
Chen", the students, but to learn the knowledge of age! Oh! It is no wonder that
even God couldn't go on.
Fourth, the children can really "infinite"? The
family went to the mountains, who sow the land? I don't understand, old man will
be able to feed the whole family retirement salary? In addition, this won't
listen to reason family, debaters say repeatedly repeatedly praise, do the other
four women argued friend willing to such family to move mountains? Even if his
descendants find daughter-in-law, where there is time to children? Even if to
give birth to the child, where have time to take care of? Even if the children
grow up, it will be the same as their parents, grandparents won't listen to
reason? Instead of endless burden future generations, rather than move to a new
world, joy can be handed down from generation to generation.
Fifth, the
great determination and courage is also unlikely to succeed. Notice the
"Taihang, Wong Uk, seven hundred, high Maninsan", it is a concept of what? Rough
calculation, two mountain about 234 trillion tons of debris. The old man put the
earth into the "Bohai Wei, north of hidden soil", even if the annual round trip,
5 tons each, to five thousand to 10000000000 years. But scientists tell us, the
earth's life total is 10000000000 years or so, that is to say when the humans
are all moved to the space, time and on the earth's infinite memory, the foolish
old man still had not destroyed the corner of mountain!
In summary, the
mountains are time-consuming and laborious, harm to others, but also violated
the laws of nature; and moving affordable, high efficiency, good prospects, and
environmental protection.
The mountain does not turn, the water turns,
water does not turn, people turn to face, so the two mountains, without a doubt,
the foolish old man should move.
Thank you.